If your business isn’t proactively engaging in the management of your web presence, you are not losing out on opportunities, you’re leaving money on the table. That’s not an overstatement. The consumers of today aren’t just buying — they are researching. They search on Google. They read reviews. If what they find doesn’t instill confidence, they go elsewhere.
This is where a professional reputation management service proves to be invaluable. More than simply protecting your brand in times of indirection, it can also be an accelerant to drive new customers into the funnel and convert them to new business.
At Otter PR, we help professionals and firms in law, healthcare, real estate, and technology build, preserve, restore, and protect their reputation. This kind of trust is indispensable for these industries, where public trust is not just optional but foundational. If you’re also looking to increase your revenue without modifying your core product or pricing model, strategic reputation marketing is likely the best route forward.
Schedule Your Free Strategy Call
What Is Reputation Marketing?
Reputation marketing is the proactive side of reputation management. This isn’t just not wanting to avoid negative press; this is wanting to use your positive press. Think: testimonials, five-star reviews, industry awards, verified media placements — these are all assets you can and should be using to close sales.
When 93% of consumers read online reviews before making a purchase, and companies with great reviews have a 31% higher conversion rate, that’s not a convenience—it’s a need to have.
At Otter PR, we assist clients in spotlighting their shining moments across the media universe. Whether that’s employing shining client testimonials for an elite-level NYC law firm or advertising five-star service ratings for a Los Angeles-based real estate company, reputation marketing is what converts trust into traction.
Reputation Marketing vs. Reputation Management: What’s the Difference?
These terms sound similar, but they’re not interchangeable. Knowing how they differ will help you get the most out of your reputation management service.
1. Purpose
- Reputation Management focuses on defending and repairing. It’s about responding to negative press or bad reviews.
- Reputation Marketing is all about amplifying the good, highlighting accolades, testimonials, success stories, and third-party endorsements.
2. Reactive vs. Proactive
- Management kicks in when a situation needs diffusing—think crisis communication or handling a wave of negative feedback.
- Marketing is proactive. It builds momentum before there’s ever a crisis, encouraging growth and brand equity.
3. Impact on Brand Growth
- Reputation Management helps you keep what you’ve built.
- Reputation Marketing helps you grow it—and fast. 90% of marketing leaders say that positive reputation tactics have a direct impact on purchasing decisions.
Real-World Examples
Take Apple. Their ads don’t just sell iPhones—they promote user satisfaction, awards, and sleek brand reputation. They lead with trust, not just features.
On the flip side, Volkswagen had to engage in heavy-duty reputation management after the emissions scandal. They didn’t promote—they had to rebuild.
A smart company uses both strategies—one to prepare for the worst, the other to build toward the best.
Why Reputation Marketing Is a Game-Changer for eCommerce
Online businesses, in particular, stand to gain big. Here’s why:
1. Reviews Drive Purchases
In a digital storefront, social proof speaks louder than any product description. Displaying verified reviews increases buying confidence and reduces friction.
2. Reputation Lifts Conversion Rates
The Spiegel Research Center found that simply adding reviews can increase conversions by up to 270%. When customers see real people vouching for your product or service, the hesitation disappears.
3. It Builds Loyalty Through Recognition
Showcasing customer experiences through testimonials, user-generated content (UGC), or reposted reviews helps people feel seen, and when customers feel valued, they stick around.
4. It Reinforces Your Credibility
Displaying client endorsements, especially for industries like law or medicine, helps position you as a reliable expert. That’s gold for high-trust fields.
5. It Boosts Your SEO
Online reviews and customer-generated content improve search rankings. When prospects search for solutions in Miami, LA, or NYC, your optimized content—and your glowing reputation—will help you show up first.
Schedule Your Free Strategy Call
Six Steps to Build a Reputation Marketing Strategy That Sells
Here’s how Otter PR helps clients implement a strategy that turns trust into revenue:
Step 1: Audit Your Online Reputation
Before you can amplify your good press, you need to know where you stand. We do a full sweep of reviews, social sentiment, and media mentions to establish your current reputation.
Step 2: Actively Collect Reviews
Encourage satisfied clients to share their experiences, especially after successful milestones. This can include surveys, follow-up emails, or incentives for feedback.
Step 3: Showcase Your Reviews Everywhere
Feature them on your homepage, product pages, LinkedIn, email campaigns—you name it. Use testimonial videos, rotating banners, and even case studies to put those great reviews to work.
Example:
Before: A generic product page with no validation.
After: A testimonial carousel, five-star badge, and a callout quote from a satisfied client—all embedded right at the decision point.
Pro tip: Use authentic customer images and quotes to boost relatability.
Step 4: Integrate Testimonials Into Ad Campaigns
Use real stories and reviews in your paid ads. Testimonials in video or quote format add social proof that can dramatically increase click-through rates and lower cost per acquisition.
Step 5: Respond and Engage
A good reputation management service does more than monitor reviews—it interacts with them. Thank happy customers, address concerns, and show you’re listening. This builds trust and can even convert critics into champions.
Pro tip: Train your team to handle reviews with professionalism, empathy, and speed.
Step 6: Track the ROI
Track the impact of your reviews on traffic, engagement, and conversions with tools such as Google Analytics, HubSpot, or Facebook Insights. Maximize the good and improve the bad.
